Reviu Satu Bintang Pembaca-Pembaca Ms. Dalloway
[Di zaman adanya Goodreads dan Amazon, teori resepsi pembaca sudah tidak relevan kerana pembaca tidak memerlukan lagi bimbingan kritikus mahupun visi asal seorang pengarang. Novel ini membosankan? Novel ini susah nak faham? Novel ini terlalu berat? Nah, ambik, kau: satu bintang! Saya juga menggunakan Goodreads dan Amazon, dan walaupun kebanyakan reviu di situ tidak boleh dipakai, kadang-kadang saya akan terjumpa "kritikan" serta amarah pembaca yang melucukan. Berikut adalah kutipan ulasan yang dibuat pembaca-pembaca Ms. Dalloway, karya Virginia Woolf, di Amazon]
written, I believe, to impress rather than to relate.
I don’t appreciate her writing and keep coming back for more
I may not be giving it a fair review since I only made it to page 65
pages and pages of surreal metaphors that go on for 10 paragraphs
Woolf had a huge obsession with semi-colons
The book just does not make any sense
I really liked the movie “the Hours”
nonsensical semi-flashbacks
Groundbreaking prose?
I tried, I really did
describing nothing
Written by a lesbian
Kind of like F. Scott Fitzgerald’s works
DO read “The Hours”, you will be impressed
I kept losing track of which character was musing about nothing
I suppose Woolf is considered a genius since she was apparently a cavalier writer of her generation
Let us listen to an old farty woman stream her consciousness to us to hear, pointless thoughts that go nowhere
I’m grateful that contemporary writers can at least string together 2 sentences that follow one another in a logical sequence
Lets burn every sentence she ever penned to end all the unneccesary suffering that curious readers have to go through when they first pick up “Mrs. Dalloway.”
My suggestion: just watch The Hours – you’ll get all the beauty and none of the confusion
the person responsible, Virginia Wolf, has been dead for quite some time now
i have no interest in reading about that lifestyle
am stuck in her growling semicolons
slower than a tortoise
ramblings of a lunatic
As bad as Faulkner
So much language
dreadfully boring
run-on sentences
“literary” drivel
terribly written
so many words
and never getting to a plot
Stream of conscience you say?
I normally enjoy stream of consciousness
The narrative reads like the inner thoughts of a sugar crazed autistic kid with ADD in the middle of a carnival
everyone i know who likes this book only does so because he or she was told by some professor that
it’s supposed to be good and can provide no evidence to confirm it
This book certainly shows the depravity of man and a self-centered life and the meaningless found amongst those who think of none but themselves.
The absence of spacing to differentiate between each character’s thought process makes for unnecessary confusion
I really liked the idea of the story taking place over the course of one day
THIS BOOK IS WORSE THAN AIDS!
meandering and repetetive
will suffice as kindling
The party! The party!
VW was mentally-ill
“Dense”
put me off
definitley not a fun read
pretty gross hair and stuff on it/ in it
I had had to read it, or was supposed to
haven’t been able to get past the first chapter
Comments